Not in africa mitch downey prepared for submission for pacdev 2018 preliminary. This research was sponsored by the deputy chief of sta. Ungoverned territories failed or failing states or ungoverned areas within otherwise viable states generate all manner of security problems and can become terrorist sanctuaries. This study examines ungoverned territories and the challenges that these. Farwell 23 analysis pakistan security issues concerning pakistans nuclear arsenal hans schippers 30 analysis afghanistan.
Ungoverned territories can also extend to airspace, for instance, air. In the intervening decade, ungoverned spaces have become a staple of the security lexicon of policymakers, analysts and researchers, and the territories the term describes thereby. The pakistaniafghan border region, in ungoverned territories. A rand project air force paf study provides this perspective by examining the factors that give rise to ungoverned territories, identifying their salient characteristics, and distinguishing among different types of ungoverned territories. Aims to root out ungoverned spaces as hotbeds of terrorism. These ungoverned territories in iraq and syria, for instance continue to pose a major international security threat, and their citizens continue to lack the basic standards of living or governance. Debt instruments of long tenure are rand ungoverned territories pdf not popular in the indian market. Ungoverned territories pose an increasingly urgent threat to u. Boko haram exploits ungoverned spaces al jazeera america. Did the invasion of afghanistan deter ungoverned spaces.
Ungoverned territories can be failed or failing states, poorly controlled land or maritime borders, or areas within otherwise viable states where the central government. Examines the sources and types of ungoverned territories and the security challenges that they. Rand ungoverned territories pdf this pdf document was made available from. Ungoverned territories can also extend to airspace, for instance, air routes. However, we need to differentiate between different kinds of ungoverned territories, and give special attention to zones of competing governance places that are governed by entities other than the forces of an established nationstate and the hierarchy of loyalties within them. Ungoverned territories are areas in which a state faces significant challenges in establishing control. To order rand documents or to obtain additional information, contact. The crimeterrorism nexus the connection between organized crime and terrorism may seem obvious but the nexus remains blurred, both conceptually and in reality. This book examines exactly when and how these spaces contribute to global insecurity, and it incorporates the many spaces where state authority is contested from tribal, sectarian, or clan.
The ungoverned is a 1985 science fiction novella by american writer vernor vinge, set between his novels the peace war and marooned in realtime. Ungoverned spaces are often cited as key threats to national and international security and are increasingly targeted by the international community for external interventionsboth armed and otherwise. Nonstate actors, ungoverned spaces and international. Ungoverned definition of ungoverned by the free dictionary. And the very existence of truly ungoverned space is questionable, as is its relationship to terrorism. First of all, governments should reevaluate the role of development agencies and donors aid. Therefore, if we want peace operations and stabilization missions to perform more anticrime and terrorism functions in the future, argues wibke hansen, then. Parts of northern kenya and nigeria fall under this category.
Lynd professor of sociology and cochair of the committee on global thought at columbia university. Ungoverned territories are areas in which a state faces signi. The recent proliferation of officially designated ungoverned spaces is attributed to two contemporary historical trendsthe apparent emergence following the. Ungoverned spaces are not just found in rural areas although typically described as somewhere akin to the tora bora caves in afghanistan or the disputed territory of galgala hills in somalia, ungoverned spaces can, and do, appear in urban environments too. It is a catchall term that does not accurately reflect the great variations between and within states. This analysis of ungoverned territories can help the united states and its friends and allies develop more effective strategies to mitigate the threats emanating from these remote territories. The pakistaniafghan border region can be regarded as the prototypical ungoverned territory. Whoever the american people elect to be our next president in november, she or he will inherit numerous problems, including terrorism, the hollowing out of nation states by narcotics traffickers, and instability in the middle east. Ungoverned territoriesfailed or failing states or ungoverned areas within otherwise viable statesgenerate a myriad of security problems and often become terrorist sanctuaries. Therefore, if we want peace operations and stabilization missions to perform more anticrime and terrorism functions in. The international law literature on ungoverned spaces, 1 such as those in somalia, congo, afghanistan, iraq, libya and syria, 2 is replete with warnings about the security threats that such places pose to states, people or the international society at large.
This book examines exactly when and how these spaces contribute to global insecurity, and it incorporates the many spaces where state authority is contestedfrom tribal, sectarian, or clan. Ungoverned spaces are often cited as key threats to national and international security and are increasingly targeted by the international community for external interventions both armed and otherwise. Each state and area within it must be seen in its own context. Governance and conflict in the sahels ungoverned space. United nations list of nonselfgoverning territories. These ungoverned territories gen erate all manner of security problems, such as civil con. Counterterrorism, ungoverned spaces, and the role of. Understanding and reducing terrorist risks, project air force santa monica, ca. Phil walter has served in the military, the intelligence community, and the interagency. Ungoverned territories can be failed or failing states, poorly controlled land or maritime borders, or areas within otherwise viable states where the central governments authority does not extend. The term ungoverned territories does not imply the complete absence of power structures in the territories in question. Support rand this pdf document was made available from.
Anarchy refers to the state of a society that totally rejects hierarchy the word originally meant leaderlessness, but pierrejoseph proudhon adopted the term in his 1840 treatise what is property. Rabasa analyzes the conditions that give rise to ungoverned territories and how they can generate terrorist safe havens. Ungovernability in this region, the suspected hideout of the core alqaeda leadership, derives from an almost complete lack of state penetration into tribal societies and high social resistance to government authority. Farwell 23 analysis pakistan security issues concerning pakistans. The views expressed here are those of the author alone and do not contain information of an official nature. Please do not distribute december 15, 2017 abstract many of the worlds poorest citizens live in peripheral spaces their states have essentially chosen not to control. The united nations list of nonselfgoverning territories is a list of places that the united nations general assembly deems to be nonselfgoverning and subject to the decolonization process. Ungoverned space, fragile states, and global threats. We mean that, in these regions, the state is absent, unable, or unwilling to perform its functions. There are, however, a range of identifiable factors that help create an. What makes an environment conducive to terrorist presence. The novella is a direct exploration of the concept of. Rabasa, senior policy analyst at the rand corporation, will join us for a discussion of ungoverned spacesfailed or failing states, and what risks they pose for international peace and u. Understanding and reducing terrorism risks, project air force, rand corporation santa monica.
Using a twotiered framework areas applied to eight case studies from around the globe, the authors seek to understand the conditions. It was first published in far frontiers, volume iii, first collected in true names and other dangers, and later published in the 1991 edition of the omnibus across realtime baen books, 1991. A project done by the research and development rand corporation has identified the policies needed to handle these areas 11. Current and projected national security threats to the united states. Global impact of terrorism 2008 regional perspectives on the threat of terrorism large urban areas of kenya and tanzania, along with their somewhat functional infrastructures and reasonably ordered societies, give outsiders the anonymity and resources they need to build their networks. Understanding and reducing terrorism risks see other formats. Many of the crises that have required intervention by u. The concept of africas ungoverned space has gained traction in the post911 era. Using a twotiered framework applied to eight cases from around the globe, the authors illustrate the conditions that give rise to ungoverned territories, contributing. Ungoverned territories eine konzeptuelle innovation im war on t error conrad schetter 187 ja coby, l. Oct, 2015 the violence and chaos inside syria, where islamic state terrorists and other rebel groups control large portions of the country, is so dire that millions of people have fled and the u.
Welcome to weak states and international relations. Since cold war, the focus of scholars remained on threat emanating from failed states to the regional and international security. Mar 10, 2015 the ungoverned space exists at the extreme end of being undergoverned or misgoverned. This is an advanced course focused on threats to the state and the system of states emerging in the 21 st century, and the challenges of. Recently, this focus has been shifted to ungoverned territories within viable states. Forest 17 analysis a weapon of violence al qaeda and taliban video james p. This study examines ungoverned territories and the challenges that these areas pose to u. Understanding and reducing terrorism risks despite its.
A rand corporation report on ungoverned spaces published in 2007 utilises four variables to measure ungovernability. Chapter xi of the united nations charter embodies a declaration on nonselfgoverning territories which declares that the interests of the occupants of dependent territories are paramount and. An ungoverned space is defined according to a rand report as. As a result, western powers have increased their footprints in africa, making the continent more militarized than at any other time since the end of the cold war. The ungoverned territories 6 february 2011 patricia mukhim one of the blessings of journalism involves forsaking the beaten track for the road less travelled. Ungoverned definition is not subjected to regulation or control. These ungoverned territories in iraq and syria, for instance continue to pose a major international security threat, and their citizens. Examines the sources and types of ungoverned territories and the security challenges that they present and proposes. Apr 28, 2015 a rand corporation report on ungoverned spaces published in 2007 utilises four variables to measure ungovernability.
Ungoverned definition and meaning collins english dictionary. Ungoverned definition of ungoverned by merriamwebster. They arise andor prosper in either ungoverned or continue reading ungoverned space. In ungoverned areas, the state has more or less ceased to exist, either by choice or unconsciously. This demonstrates the prevalent politicalgeographic approach to ungoverned space that is contingent upon ungoverned space as a definable, demarcated territory within a fragile state and moreover, is predicated upon an innate link between fragile states and ungoverned space, which does not compensate for pockets of ungoverned space in the. The violence and chaos inside syria, where islamic state terrorists and other rebel groups control large portions of the country, is so dire that millions of people have fled and the u. Thoughts on the nature and consequences of ungoverned spaces. The pentagon soon launched an ungoverned areas project pdf and directed its combatant commands to build the capacity of fragile states to control their borders and territories. Ungoverned territories or new types of rights and authority.
Jan 11, 2010 the pentagon soon launched an ungoverned areas project pdf and directed its combatant commands to build the capacity of fragile states to control their borders and territories. Lamn area in which a state faces significant challenges in establishing control. The rand corporation is a nonprofit research organization providing. On one such trip to the eastern part of arunachal pradesh, adjacent to namdapha national park in changlang district, i met a group of people who called themselves the lisu and occupy that. Th ey can be failed or failing states, poorly controlled land or maritime borders, or areas within otherwise viable states to which the central governments authority does not extend. Ungoverned territories can be failed or failing states, poorly controlled land or maritime borders or. All of these problems have at least one thing in common. Rand to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of our research documents for. Until recently, ungoverned territories were of little interest to the u.
712 730 1023 111 887 1304 262 501 1267 273 1157 836 1036 1427 86 1516 1282 1106 104 421 546 331 236 567 579 557 1116 1095 875 485 922 718 278 365 779 521 467 1283 358 1320 426 471 271 1018